Pacifier Holder vs. Pacifier Clips: Which One Should You Buy?

Table of Contents

  1. Intro: Baby Essentials — Tiny But So Important

  2. What is a Pacifier Clip?

    • Functionality

    • Pros & Cons

  3. What is a Pacifier Holder?

    • Purpose

    • Pros & Cons

  4. Pacifier Clip vs Pacifier Holder: Key Differences

    • Use Case

    • Cleanliness & Hygiene

    • Safety

    • Portability

    • Style & Personalization

  5. When to Use What?

  6. Mistakes Parents Make While Choosing

  7. Our Verdict: Which One Wins?

  8. Conclusion

  9. FAQs

Introduction

Let's be real — babies are adorable little packages of happiness, but they're also masters at tossing things. particularly their favorite pacifiers. So how do you rescue the day (and your sanity)? You need either a clip or a holder — or perhaps both?

Also, while we’re on baby care must-haves, don’t forget daily hygiene too! A silicone toothbrush for babies helps keep gums clean even before those tiny teeth show up.

What is a Pacifier Clip?

Paci clip is a little strap that has a closure on one side (for the paci) and a clip on the other side (for baby's clothing). Its purpose? To have pacifier at finger tips and OUT of the way of the floor.

Advantages:

  • Saves having to find lost pacifiers every 5 minutes

  • Keeps pacifier off germy floor

  • Usually adorable, personalized appearance

  • Facilitates babies easy self-soothing

Disadvantages:

  • Should not be stored with multiple pacifiers

  • Needs to be removed during sleep times

  • Long cords = no-no (choking hazard, so only use safety-tested ones)

What is a Pacifier Holder?

Consider it like a lil' storage pouch or box designed to keep your pacifiers safe and clean when you're not using them. You toss it in your diaper bag or purse and have a clean backup always available.

Pros:

  • Clean storage for spare pacifiers

  • Excellent for diaper bags and travel

  • Keeps dust, germs, and lint off

Cons:

  • Not helpful during active use

  • May be misplaced in a large diaper bag without a clip or loop

  • Not all holders are air-vented, which can cause moisture build-up

Pacifier Clip vs Pacifier Holder: Key Differences

Feature

Pacifier Clip

Pacifier Holder

Function

Keeps pacifier attached to baby

Stores pacifiers when not in use

Hygiene

Prevents floor drops

Seals pacifiers from dirt and bacteria

Safety

Must meet length & material guidelines

Must be BPA-free & easy to sanitize

Portability

Clipped to baby’s outfit

Fits in diaper bag

Style Factor

Comes in adorable, custom designs

Usually plain or neutral designs


When to Use What?

Employ Pacifier Clips on walks, stroller excursions, car rides, or when baby's playing at home — anytime they're using the pacifier actively.

Employ Pacifier Holders for storing extra pacifiers in the diaper bag, or when going out to daycare, doctor's appointment, or overnights.

Honestly? They're like Batman & Robin — better together.

Mistakes Parents Make While Choosing

  • Parents' Mistakes When Selecting

  • Purchasing clips that are too long (not safe, even if they appear cute)

  • Not looking for BPA-free material in holders

  • Failing to regularly sanitize pacifier holders

  • Wearing clips while baby sleeps (it's not safe!)

  • Picking clips with small beads or parts that will break off

Our Verdict: Which One Wins?

If I had to choose one — the clip takes it for everyday wear. It saves you from loss, saves you and baby from stress, and brings a lil' personality to your baby's OOTD?

But TBH, both do diff jobs and it's smart to have both. Clips for go-time. Holders for back-up storage.

Conclusion

There is no right or wrong option — only what works best with your baby's schedule. A pacifier clip is hygienic and at hand, and a pacifier holder is your on-the-go hygiene sidekick.

And if you're already assembling your baby arsenal, don't leave out useful travel-sized tools like our Silicone Spoon with travel case. Because clean, safe eating counts just as much as clean, safe comforting.

FAQs

Q1. Can I use a pacifier clip and a pacifier holder?

  • Yes! Use the clip during use and the holder to store extras or keep it clean in your purse.

Q2. Are pacifier clips safe?

  • Yes, provided that they are short, BPA-free, and safety compliant. Steer clear of clips with tiny beads or sharp metal edges.

Q3. How do I clean a pacifier holder?

  • Most can be cleaned with a baby-safe disinfectant. Silicone ones may be washed with soap and water.

Q4. Is it safe for baby to sleep with pacifier clip on?

  • Nope! Always take it off before nap or bedtime to prevent any chance of entanglement.

Back to What's Brewing